CrossBinge
Finding 41.241 movie posters in the basement
CrossBingeCrossBinge
All guides →
CrossBinge Guide

Every Version of Love, Simon

From a YA novel about a closeted teen to a landmark studio film and a sprawling TV spinoff universe, the story of Simon Spier is now a whole cross-media franchise.

A Letter That Started Everything

Becky Albertalli published Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda in 2015, and the YA world immediately understood it was something different. Not darker or edgier than other queer teen fiction, just warmer: a funny, propulsive, genuinely romantic story about a closeted sixteen-year-old in suburban Georgia who falls for an anonymous classmate he only knows as "Blue." The novel's central argument, that gay teens deserve the same light, fizzy, unserious rom-com experience straight teens had always had, turned out to be commercially and culturally irresistible.

Three years later, 20th Century Fox adapted it as Love, Simon (2018), becoming the first major Hollywood studio release built around a gay teenage romance. The film's success made the case clearly enough that Hulu greenlit Love, Victor, a spinoff TV series set in the same fictional Creekwood universe, which ran for three seasons from 2020 to 2022. Meanwhile Albertalli kept writing in the same world: Leah on the Offbeat (2018) centers on Simon's best friend Leah Burke, and Yes No Maybe So (co-written with Adam Silvera, 2020) extends the same inclusive, sunny sensibility to a new pair of protagonists. The story has not traveled as far across media as some franchises, but what it has crossed into, it has crossed into well.

Every Version of Love, Simon

The source, the adaptation, the spinoffs, and the companion stories

Simon's Story, Year by Year

The definitive version is the 2018 film

Greg Berlanti's Love, Simon does what great adaptations do: it takes the emotional core of the book and amplifies it for the screen without losing the lightness. Nick Robinson's performance carries the film, but the real achievement is structural. The anonymous email conceit translates perfectly to a format that keeps the audience in the same suspense as Simon. The novel is warm and funny; the film is warm and funny and adds a genuinely lovely third act. It was also a genuine cultural moment, the kind that does not repeat.

Love, Victor runs out of road by season 3

Love, Victor earns its first season easily: Michael Cimino is compelling, the Creekwood setting gives it an immediate familiarity, and the show finds its own identity rather than retracing Simon's steps. Season 2 stretches the premise but holds together. By season 3, the writers are manufacturing obstacles for a cast that has already resolved everything interesting about them. Stop after season 2 and you will have had a genuinely good time.

If you love it for the coming-out story

Other queer stories told with honesty and warmth across film and TV

If you love it for the anonymous romance

Stories built on hidden identities, secret correspondences, and revealed feelings

If you love it for the suburban high school setting

Coming-of-age stories that make ordinary American adolescence feel specific and alive

More Tender Coming of Age Stories

Companion guide

Coming of Age

Explore the Coming of Age guide →
Every version of this story argues the same thing: that a gay teenager's first love is worth exactly the same amount of screen time, page count, and unironic feeling as anyone else's.CrossBinge editors