
Romance could make this household very awkward. Bobby Moynihan told Vulture he pitches Rusty falling for Monica in The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins. His account of Erika Alexander’s response is wonderfully brief.
He laughs as he says it. This is his pitch, not a confirmed storyline.
The show’s official premise already gives relationships plenty to withstand. Reggie is a disgraced football star trying to regain his family’s respect and his fans’ admiration. A filmmaker arrives to help repair his image. Monica is his ex-wife; Rusty is his friend. There are easier households in which to look for romance.
My instinct is to keep the suggestion in reserve. A sitcom does not need to couple everybody off to give them a reason to stay. Friendship can be demanding, ridiculous and possessive without becoming courtship. I would rather see a sidekick want something inconvenient than assume that the thing he wants must eventually become his reward.
The funniest version of a wish is often the stretch before anybody grants it. A sidekick with a private ambition suddenly has something to protect, and being loyal becomes a choice with a cost. That is useful comic pressure even if the romance never goes anywhere.
There is also a difference between wanting more time with a character and wanting the show to rearrange itself around him. A supporting player can make an entrance feel like an event. Give him everything he wants and you might remove the very frustration that made the entrance welcome. Moynihan’s idea is entertaining to imagine precisely because it would make keeping everyone comfortable so difficult.
Season two began on November 2. In the US, new episodes air on NBC on Mondays and arrive on Peacock the following day; the earlier season is also there. The streaming page lists episodes around twenty minutes long, which makes trying one a fairly small commitment.
If you are new, begin with the first season and meet this household before deciding whom to pair up. For existing viewers, the next episode arrives on Peacock on November 17. A short weekly comedy is a welcome thing to fit between longer commitments.